A trackball is not as correct as a good-quality mouse, however it may be extra exact than a trackpad for anybody trying to remove repetitive movement from mousing round an excessive amount of. Though trackballs may also help some folks with some signs of repetitive stress damage, they cannot assist everybodywe suggest consulting a physician first should you’re contemplating a trackball for that purpose.
Table of Contents
Why it is best to belief us
Earlier than becoming a member of Wirecutter, I spent six years at Lifehacker writing about expertise. For this information, I used every model of trackball for per week earlier than assessing particular person fashions. Throughout this analysis, I laid palms on virtually each obtainable trackball.
We additionally spoke with Alan Hedge, director of the Human Components and Ergonomics Laboratory at Cornell College and one of many nation’s foremost ergonomicists, to be taught who may profit from switching from a standard mouse or trackpad to a trackball.
The very best finger-operated trackball: Kensington Professional Mouse
The Kensington Professional Mouse Wi-fi Trackball is the most effective finger-operated trackball as a result of its massive ball is responsive and easy, the design is snug for each right- and left-handed folks, and its 4 buttons are straightforward to customise with Kensington’s software program. It connects through both a 2.four GHz wi-fi dongle or Bluetooth, and the included AA batteries present lengthy battery life. It normally prices between $60 and $80, however the premium construct high quality, well-crafted ball, and variety of buttons make it definitely worth the worth. If you don’t need wi-fi, take into account the marginally cheaper however in any other case similar wired model of the Professional Mouse.
The Kensington Professional Mouse’s 55 mm ball (almost the dimensions of a pool ball) strikes freely and easily. The ball’s massive dimension makes it simpler to maneuver your cursor throughout high-resolution shows or throughout a number of displays than the smaller balls of the Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring and the Logitech MX Ergo. To take away the ball, simply pull it out or flip the Professional Mouse over. Useless-skin gunk accumulates beneath the ball, because it does with each trackball, so we suggest doing this each couple of weeks.
The Professional Mouse’s 4 massive buttons have a crisp click on that does not really feel mushy or hole, not like the buttons on our finances decide, the Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring. By default, the Professional Mouse’s two backside buttons are right- and left-click, whereas the 2 high buttons are ahead and again.
As a substitute of a scroll wheel, the Professional Mouse has a scroll ring across the ball. However the scroll ring felt gritty after we turned it, as if two items of steel had been skimming throughout one another. Many house owners report the identical downside, and Wirecutter senior editor Dan Frakes has skilled it, too: “It is a disgrace the trackball itself works so easily, however the scroll ring feels so jerky and janky.” Kensington representatives advised us that “this goes away with some use” after which “the scroll ring turns into very easy and usable with none noise.” After a few week I modified my scrolling approach to have a lighter contact and decrease the resistance, but it surely’s nonetheless simply as gritty. Our finances decide, the Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring, does not endure from this downside. Should you love the Professional Mouse however cannot cope with the gritty scroll ring, you’ll be able to take it aside, take away a magnet, and add some lubricant your self.
The finger-operated Professional Mouse does not drive your hand into one place like a thumb-operated trackball does, that means you should use your palm or whichever fingers you would like to manage the ball. The ball’s dimension and site permit for broad arm actions, that are surprisingly enjoyable to do and useful for ergonomics you probably have bother bending your wrist. The ambidextrous design works for each right- and left-handed folks.
The Professional Mouse’s slope, with the again larger than the entrance, could make it tough to function ergonomically. To appropriate for this, the Professional Mouse comes with a removable leatherette-covered wrist relaxation to prop the hand in a impartial place. This part makes the Professional Mouse over 9 inches deep, so it may be too large for some work areas. It is also fairly heavy, weighing 396 g with out the wrist relaxation; it stays placed on a desk however is a poor selection for moveable use.
Kensington’s TrackballWorks software program permits you to customise button conduct, scroll pace, and pointer pace, in addition to to set shortcuts for pushing two buttons on the identical time. You may as well arrange a keystroke to provoke a precision mode that slows down the cursor, and customise button conduct per utility. The pointer-acceleration slider is helpful you probably have a number of displays, and it is a characteristic that Logitech’s Choices software program lacks. In any other case, the Kensington software program has the identical fundamental options as Logitech Choices and the older Logitech Management Middle, and is equally straightforward to make use of. On a Mac, the Kensington software program works provided that you have related the trackball through the USB-A dongle, not Bluetooth. That is annoying, and we want the corporate would repair it, as a result of newer Macs have solely USB-C ports and require an adapter for USB-A. (Logitech Choices, against this, works simply superb with Bluetooth connections on a Mac.)
We did not have the time to check battery life, however Kensington advised us you may get round six to eight months of use out of two AA batteries with Bluetooth, or as much as a yr should you’re utilizing the USB dongle. The Professional Mouse has an influence change on the underside but additionally turns itself off robotically after inactivity to avoid wasting battery life. The rechargeable Logitech MX Ergo guarantees round 4 months of battery life, and the Logitech M570 is the most effective of the bunch we examined with an estimated 18 months of life on a single AA battery.
We did not have any connection points with the Professional Mouse through the dongle or Bluetooth. (We suggest utilizing the USB dongle should you’re on a Mac, nevertheless, due to the dearth of software program help for a Bluetooth connection.)
The Professional Mouse is dear, however the construct high quality and 4 programmable buttons make it definitely worth the worth over the Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring, which has solely two buttons and is on the market completely as a wired mannequin.
Kensington gives a three-year guarantee for the Professional Mouse, in distinction to the Logitech MX Ergo’s one-year guarantee. That mentioned, most points ought to come up within the first yr, so though it is helpful to know that you would be able to bug Kensington with points three years after buy, most individuals most likely will not have to. The Professional Mouse has constructive evaluations from Wired and ZDNet, and at this writing it has a ranking of three.9 stars (out of 5) on Amazon throughout 2,201 evaluations.
Finances finger-operated trackball: Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring
The Kensington Orbit Trackball with Scroll Ring sometimes prices a 3rd as a lot because the Professional Mouse however has a smaller ball and gives solely two buttons as a substitute of 4. It makes use of solely a wired connection, not wi-fi, so you do not have to fret about battery-life or connection points. It is flatter than the Professional Mouse, which will be extra snug, and the scroll ring strikes extra slowly. Should you’ve by no means used a trackball earlier than and are uncertain about them, the Orbit with Scroll Ring is an efficient mannequin to start out with as a result of it is inexpensive and straightforward to make use of.
At 40 mm, the ball is smaller than that of the Professional Mouse (55 mm) however greater than the one within the MX Ergo (34 mm). You need to use it on multiple-monitor setups, however you will have to bump up the sensitivity greater than on the Professional Mouse. In our exams, the Orbit with Scroll Ring wasn’t as enjoyable to make use of because the Professional Mouse as a result of it did not facilitate equally broad arm actions, and the smaller ball was a bit much less exact. You may clear this mannequin the identical method because the Professional Mousesimply pop the ball out and wipe any gunk inside.
The suitable- and left-click buttons really feel hole and low-costlike these on a freebie mouse included with a pcin contrast with the Professional Mouse’s sturdy, crisp buttons. Though the scroll ring is chintzy plastic, it feels a lot smoother to scroll than the gritty wheel of the Professional Mouse. The comfortable plastic exterior feels hole, and at 144 g the Orbit with Scroll Ring lacks the Professional Mouse’s heft, but it surely stays placed on a desk.
The Orbit with Scroll Ring is snug to make use of right- or left-handed, and the 2 buttons on both facet of the trackball are straightforward to succeed in. As a result of it lacks the Professional Mouse’s steep slope, it sits flatter on a desk. Kensington features a removable wrist relaxation, however that piece is far smaller than the wrist relaxation for the Professional Mouse and is not as helpful given this system’s flatter profile.
The Orbit with Scroll Ring makes use of the identical Kensington TrackballWorks software program because the Professional Mouse and in addition comes with a five-year guarantee. Along with constructive evaluations from CNET and PCMag, the Orbit with Scroll Ring at present has a four.2-star ranking (out of 5) on Amazon, throughout 1,611 evaluations.
Finest thumb-operated trackball: Logitech MX Ergo
Should you desire a thumb-operated trackball, we suggest the Logitech MX Ergo Wi-fi Trackball. The ball, whereas small, is easy and straightforward to make use of, and the MX Ergo can tilt 20 levels to supply a extra snug place. The Logitech Choices software program has many of the settings you should customise the MX Ergo and its eight buttons. Logitech claims the MX Ergo’s rechargeable battery will final round 4 months, and the MX Ergo can join wirelessly through Bluetooth or the Logitech Unifying dongle. It normally prices about $100, on the pricier finish of trackballs, however its glorious construct high quality and fashionable software program make it price the associated fee.
The MX Ergo’s 34 mm grey ball is smaller than these of each the Professional Mouse and the Orbit with Scroll Ring, however the identical dimension because the M570’s blue ball. With this smaller ball you should put in additional effort to maneuver the cursor throughout the display: Utilizing the Kensington Professional Mouse, you’ll be able to transfer a cursor throughout a 4K monitor with a small swipe, however on the MX Ergo it takes a few turns of the ball, even you probably have the pointer pace set to most. To take away the ball, you should shove a skinny stick (akin to a chopstick; pens will not match) by means of a gap beneath the system. As with the Professional Mouse, it is best to do that each couple of weeks to filter out dead-skin bits and different gunk.
The MX Ergo has eight programmable buttonstwice as many because the Professional Mouse, and three greater than the M570and one non-programmable button on high to modify between paired computer systems. The MX Ergo’s greatest enchancment over its predecessor, the M570, is the scroll wheel. Whereas the M570 has a gummy, hollow-feeling scroll wheel that may’t tilt, the MX Ergo’s scroll wheel produces a nice, refined ratchet and may tilt proper and left for vertical scrolling (or no matter else you program it to do). Like each different trackball we examined, the MX Ergo lacks quick scrolling. If you should make small actions, this mannequin has a button on the facet to toggle precision mode, however I by no means used it and ended up reprogramming it.
The MX Ergo has a comfortable plastic coating with a bit on the underside proper molded to suit a pinky. It is snug to carry, and in my exams all of the buttons had been straightforward to succeed in for my average-size palms. The MX Ergo comes with a magnetic steel stand that permits you to maintain it flat or angle the system at 20 levels; I discovered this upright angle extra snug, however the MX Ergo works completely nicely in both place, so it is best to be capable of discover a good impartial place to your setup. At a weight of 263 g, the MX Ergo is far heavier than the 138 g M570.
The MX Ergo helps the easy-to-use Logitech Choices software program for Home windows and macOS. You may reprogram the MX Ergo’s buttons and set them to behave otherwise based mostly on the applying you are utilizing. Choices, like Logitech’s older Management Middle software program, lacks the pointer-acceleration slider that Kensington’s TrackballWorks consists of, a characteristic that is particularly helpful for trackballs on multiple-monitor setups; you need to arrange acceleration for the MX Ergo within the working system’s settings as a substitute. The MX Ergo additionally helps Logitech Stream, which helps you to transfer the cursor between a number of computer systemseven between a Mac and a Home windows machineon the identical community and duplicate or drag information from one laptop to a different.
Logitech claims the MX Ergo’s battery will final 4 monthstwo months lower than Kensington’s estimated battery life for the Professional Mouse, and method lower than Logitech’s 18-month estimate for the M570. Not like each of these fashions, nevertheless, the MX Ergo makes use of a chargeable inner battery as a substitute of AA batteries. And it has a fast-charge characteristic that Logitech says will give it sufficient juice for a full workday in a minute of cost. (We weren’t capable of take a look at this characteristic, since our MX Ergo hasn’t but run out of battery life in our testing.)
You may join the MX Ergo to 2 computer systems concurrently through Bluetooth or a Logitech Unifying dongle; utilizing a button on high of the MX Ergo, you’ll be able to swap between the computer systems. We did not run into any connection points, and after I pressed the button, the MX Ergo swapped shortly between a MacBook and a Home windows laptop.
Sometimes priced round $100, the MX Ergo is normally 4 occasions as costly as our finances thumb-operated decide, the M570. The MX Ergo has a tilt characteristic, two extra buttons, newer software program, Bluetooth, and a extra fashionable design, options we expect are worthwhile for most individuals contemplating a trackball. However should you do not want these issues, the M570 is an efficient trackball that is significantly cheaper.
The MX Ergo has a one-year restricted guaranteeshorter protection than the three-year warranties of the M570 and Professional Mouse, and the five-year guarantee of the Orbit with Scroll Ringhowever many of the defects the guarantee covers normally seem throughout the first yr. The MX Ergo has constructive evaluations from Gizmodo, Laptop computer Magazine, PCMag, and TechRadar, and at this writing it has a four.2-star ranking (out of 5) on Amazon throughout 212 evaluations.
Finances thumb-operated trackball: Logitech M570
If the MX Ergo is simply too costly, or if you’d like the most cost effective good introduction to the world of trackballs, get the Logitech M570 Wi-fi Trackball. The M570 prices a few quarter as a lot as its successor, the MX Ergo, and it is a stable trackball regardless of its outdated design and software program. It feels mild and low-cost subsequent to the MX Ergo, and it lacks the MX Ergo’s tilt characteristic, however in any other case the M570 is snug. And should you do not want Bluetooth or further buttons, the M570 is simply as helpful because the MX Ergo.
The M570’s blue ball is identical dimension because the MX Ergo’s grey one, and the 2 are equally easy and straightforward to rotate. As with the MX Ergo, the M570 takes extra effort to maneuver a cursor throughout the display than the Kensington Professional Mouse’s bigger trackball. The M570 has a much bigger gap on the underside than the MX Ergo, which makes popping the trackball out for cleansing simpler; for this activity, virtually any pen will work on the M570, whereas the MX Ergo wants one thing the thickness of a chopstick.
The M570 has 5 buttons: left- and right-click, ahead and again buttons, and a clickable scroll wheel. The M570 lacks a precision-mode button, and its scroll wheel can not tilt just like the MX Ergo’s. The scroll wheel’s easy plastic additionally feels low-cost and gummy, particularly subsequent to the MX Ergo’s responsive scroll wheel. However the M570 is considerably lighter than the MX Ergo, so it is a greater moveable possibility, and it nonetheless stays placed on a desk throughout on a regular basis use.
Much like the MX Ergo, the M570 is fabricated from molded plastic with a small divot for a pinky to relaxation on. Whereas the MX Ergo has a soft-touch plastic coating, the M570 is roofed in a easy, onerous plastic. However the M570’s decade-old easy design appears to be like dated in contrast with the fashionable industrial design of the MX Ergo. Though the M570 lacks the MX Ergo’s tilt characteristic, it rests flatter on a desk.
The M570 is not suitable with Logitech Choices; it makes use of the older Logitech Management Middle software program as a substitute. Management Middle has an outdated interface, and Logitech might not help it as lengthy, however it could actually do all the identical issues as Logitech Choices (besides Logitech Stream).
Logitech guarantees 18 months of battery life for the AA-powered M570; judging from Amazon evaluations, that declare appears correct. The M570 does not help Bluetooth just like the MX Ergo and Kensington Professional Mouse do, but it surely nonetheless connects wirelessly, through the Logitech Unifying USB dongle. We did not have any connection points.
The M570 comes with a three-year guarantee. Contemplating it is an older system with 13,00zero Amazon evaluations and a ranking of four.four stars (out of 5) as of late, we do not see a lot going flawed with the M570 that you simply would not catch within the first yr of use. The M570 additionally has constructive evaluations from PCMag and Engadget.
Must you change to a trackball?
In a survey (DOCX) printed by trackball maker Kensington, respondents listed their high three causes for switching to a trackball: pace and accuracy, ergonomics, and an absence of mouse area.
Trackballs will be helpful for folks with a repetitive pressure damage of their shoulder or wrist as a result of utilizing these gadgets requires completely different muscle groups than utilizing a mouse. Cornell ergonomicist Alan Hedge identified to us that a trackball is most helpful if it helps you retain your hand within the appropriate place: “The important thing to soundly utilizing both a trackball (or a mouse) is to function the system with the hand in a impartial posture (this implies the hand is straight and degree, not bent up, down, left or proper, or twisted).” This impartial place is less complicated to keep up with a trackball as a result of not like a mouse, a trackball does not transfer. Hedge continued, “Relatively than extending the hand upwards to permit the fingers to maneuver the ball, it’s higher to make use of flat fingers or the palm of the hand to rotate the ball.”
Trackballs are available in two variations: finger-operated and thumb-operated. Finger-operated trackballs place the ball within the heart, so you should use them right- or left-handed. And so they usually have a bigger ball, which makes it simpler to fling the cursor throughout a bigger area, akin to on a 4K monitor or throughout a number of displays. Thumb-operated fashions look extra like conventional mice however have a trackball on the left facet, so that they’re snug just for individuals who mouse right-handed (which is nearly everybody). Since thumb-operated trackballs feel and appear extra like a standard mouse, with a scroll wheel set between two high buttons, they’re simpler to get the grasp of. However their smaller ball requires extra effort to maneuver the cursor throughout the display, so that they’re higher fitted to use on single displays or low-resolution shows.
Thumb-operated trackballs will not work for everybody. “Overuse of the thumb may end up in De Quervain’s Tenosynovitis, the place extending the thumb turns into a painful motion,” Hedge advised us. “A finger-operated trackball permits for the finger to be flat and for it to slip backwards and forwards over the ball to maneuver the ball, which can scale back damage threat.” That notion tracks with our testing expertise: We discovered that finger-operated trackballs inspired higher ergonomicsfull arm actions and impartial wrist posturein contrast with thumb-operated fashions. We have additionally seen complaints on-line about thumb ache from utilizing thumb-operated trackballs, however we did not expertise any ache in our testing. And many individuals have used thumb-operated trackballs for years and even a long time with no issues.
After affected by RSI almost 20 years in the past, Wirecutter senior editor Dan Frakes switched to Kensington’s large trackballs on the recommendation of a physician, and has used varied iterations of the Professional Mousefrom the early ADB Turbo Mouse by means of the present wi-fi mannequinever since. He mentioned making bigger pointer actions with the whole arm and making smaller actions by rotating the arm and wrist (as a substitute of bending the wrist) have helped him keep away from hand and wrist ache. “Plus, it is simply enjoyable to fling the pointer throughout two shows by spinning the ball,” Dan added. However RSI relies on the kind of work you do and your desk setup. There is no common resolution, so speak together with your physician to see if a trackball might be helpful.
Within the Kensington survey, contributors who used trackballs over mice mentioned they discovered them simpler to manage for exact actions. Trackballs aren’t as exact as a stylus, however they’re extra helpful for on a regular basis use. We additionally discovered trackballs extra exact than trackpads and extra usable for design work or anything that required accuracy. Since trackballs usually have 4 (or extra) buttons, they’re simpler to customise than trackpads, which depend on gestures for fundamental actions. Even with the sensitivity cranked up, trackballs do not transfer the cursor as quick as high-dots-per-inch (high-DPI) mice, however a superb one can fling a cursor throughout a high-resolution display almost as shortly. Most trackballs use optical sensors, simply as most mice do, however their DPI is usually unpublished, or so low (sometimes round 400) that it is not an necessary issue to think about. Evaluating the DPI of a trackball with that of a standard mouse is not useful both, because the two forms of gadgets management so otherwise.
Since trackballs do not transfer in your desk, they do not require as a lot area as a mouse. This issue makes them a sensible choice to be used on small desks, on the go, or once you want a pointing system however haven’t got a tough floor obtainable, like on a sofa. Not like a mouse, which ultimately hits the sting of a desk, it is unattainable to expire of area with a trackball because it rotates infinitely.
How we picked
We discovered the next options to be an important in our analysis and testing:
Ball: A trackball ought to rotate easily, with out gritty-feeling friction. A low-quality ball can smash the expertise of utilizing a trackball. The larger the trackball, the much less rotation you should transfer the cursor throughout the display. Buttons: We appeared for a similar quantity of buttons as we do on wi-fi micea trackball ought to have not less than right- and left-click buttons, however we most well-liked fashions with not less than two extra buttons for again and ahead. Consolation: A trackball needs to be snug for any dimension hand and never require wrist extension or deviation to function. Software program: In case your trackball mouse has greater than 4 buttons, you may doubtless need to customise how they work with producer software program. Nice software program may even allow you to change the pointer pace, acceleration, and scrolling pace. Battery life: Should you go for a wi-fi trackball, you’ll be able to anticipate not less than 4 to 6 months of battery life. Some trackballs use AA batteries and others have a chargeable battery. Connection: Some wi-fi choices help a 2.four GHz USB wi-fi receiver (a dongle), Bluetooth, or each. Every connection kind offers a robust sign that does not reduce out over quick distances. Value: The newest fashions with fashionable software program and higher construct high quality are inclined to value $70 to $100. Older trackballs with older software program, fewer buttons, and wired connections can be found for $20 to $40. Guarantee: Most issues with trackballs come from quality-control quirks and floor within the first yr (if not within the first week) of use, so we anticipate to see not less than a one-year guarantee. Longer warranties are good however not required.
How we examined
In Kensington’s trackball survey (DOCX), many respondents mentioned they took round per week to get the grasp of utilizing a trackball, so we spent per week with every model of trackball. We then used every contender for not less than eight hours of labor earlier than eliminating fashions that had been awkward to make use of, suffered from build-quality points, or had complicated software program. Then we used the remaining trackballs for a number of days of labor, taking note of the construct high quality, accuracy, and normal consolation. For wi-fi fashions, we made certain the sign did not reduce out.
The competitors
The Kensington Professional Mouse Wired Trackball is almost similar to our finger-operated decide, the wi-fi Professional Mouse, apart from its wired connection and completely different colours. We did not take a look at this model, however proprietor evaluations recommend it has the identical grittiness within the scroll ring. Should you do not want wi-fi connectivity, you’ll be able to normally save somewhat cash by going with the wired model.
As a substitute of utilizing a hardware scroll ring as on the Kensington Professional Mouse and Orbit with Scroll Ring, with the Kensington SlimBlade Trackball you need to rotate the ball to scroll, which is hard to do with out bouncing the cursor across the display. The SlimBlade’s buttons really feel hole in contrast with the Professional Mouse’s, and its shiny plastic and steel surfaces appeal to fingerprints.
The Kensington Orbit Optical Trackball feels low-cost and tends to slip round on a desk as a result of it is mild and its rubber ft aren’t sticky sufficient. It does not offer you a technique to scroll apart from urgent the Scroll Lock key in your keyboard and shifting the ball, which requires some important rewiring in your mind to get the grasp of.
Though the Logitech TrackMan Marble lacks a scroll wheel or ring, it has buttons for paging up and down. The TrackMan Marble bears a form much like that of the Kensington Orbit with Scroll Ring, however the button placement makes unintentionally hitting the page-up and page-down buttons too straightforward; even after just a few days of use, we by no means acquired snug with that placement.
The Elecom M-HT1DRBK is a cult favourite, however we by no means acclimated to the button location or trackball place. It is filled with eight keys and even has a DPI change and a scroll wheel on the facet. It is also large, taking over much more desk area than the Kensington Professional Mouse. We had been unable to get the software program engaged on a Mac, and the Home windows software program is not translated nicely into English, which makes it awkward to make use of.
Due to these software program quirks, in addition to a brief six-month guarantee and middling Amazon evaluations that point out quality-control points, we did not take a look at the remainder of Elecom’s trackball line. They’re in style in fanatic circles, although, and should you do not thoughts coping with awkward software program, Elecom is the one firm that makes a left-handed thumb-operated trackball.
What to sit up for
CST, the corporate behind a number of fashions of fanatic trackballs, has bought its line to P.I. Engineering. Subsequently, none of its trackballs are at present obtainable to buy. As soon as they’re again in manufacturing, we plan on testing the brand new fashions.
This information might have been up to date by Wirecutter. To see the present suggestion, please go right here.
When readers select to purchase Wirecutter’s independently chosen editorial picks, Wirecutter and Engadget might earn affiliate commissions.
Related Posts:
